Why I was Banned from Medium
https://foxyfox.substack.com/publish/post/143208606
Introduction
I have probably found out why I was banned from medium. It was slightly different to what I had thought.
I had decided to try the Medium blogging platform as I was suspended as it turned out temporarily from wordpress. I signed up to Medium and was testing their gallery facility. I needed a gallery facility that could take many photos and arrange them well, as I had intended to post about 30 screenshots from a video about symbolism.
Suspension
This is the message, I received...
I appealed as I thought it was an algorithm error, and I was expecting routine reinstatement of account but I was told the account was in violation of the rules, for hateful content.
This surprised me. I therefore asked for the specific photo that was hateful. I received a reply from someone ironically, whose name / pseudonym was Liberty from User Services.
Liberty informed me that the account would remain suspended and the decision was final, but he /him did at least give me the image that was deemed hateful.
In my haste of blog testing/ being banned, I had overlooked that I had already posted the first photo in the folder as a test, before moving onto loading a full gallery. In fact the meme I think was wrongly filed in that folder and should have been in my Spot the Symbolism folder, social comment section.
The first photo/screenshot in the file was this meme, and I had test posted one photo / screenshot, a title and a line of text.
The Offending Meme
Until I accessed what I had written, I had thought that it must have been something in my post on Walter Veith symbolism that I had been banned for. In the end it looks like it was not, it was for the meme that was wrongly filed in my Walter Veith folder. (I have not rewatched the Veith video, but very much doubt if it was in there, I think it was from twitter, misfiled).
I had not examined the meme, I had seen the writing, the freemason logo and a court scene. I had no inkling why it was thought hateful. My first idea was when I did a reverse image search on TinEye to try and find out where the meme was from.
Unfortunately the results given were limited and I did not source the meme from there, but maybe twitter is not covered in the search.
One of the links [2] gave this...
So the name which included the letters zion gave me a clue as to why I may have been banned though it is supposition.
I presume that the meme has been judged as antisemitic. I re-examined the meme and perhaps the freemasons face is thought to look like a stereotype.
I certainly did not realise at the time I posted that the meme was about that, if it is. I thought it was about freemasons and justice.
Discussion
What I thought was just a freemasonic meme, may have had undertones of a meme also against others.
Even if it did, should that have led to permanent ban, especially with no prior warning? Even if the meme was determined to use a "trope" is that a reason to ban me permanently from medium? Should it not be allowed? Some people like Rachel Riley are allowed to use that trope, yet me not knowing that a trope was even being used, even if it was, am banned from Medium for using it unwittingly. Even the whole idea of these tropes appears designed to prevent justificable criticism of certain sectors. Even now, writing this I am having to tiptoe.
‘To Learn Who Rules Over You, Simply Find Out Who You Are Not Allowed To Criticise’
A source states that that quote originated with white nationalist writer Kevin Alfred Strom. What a nightmare it is trying to write a blog these days!
I think I dodged a bullet with the Medium though, all things considered. Liberty and free speech does not seem to be their priority. Even if I was not banned on my very first post, it inevitably would have come anyway, after I had put more effort into the blog.
Wordpress Suspensions
Were my suspensions on 2 different wordpress blogs related - foxblog2 and foxblog4? One of those blogs did contain the meme as I had loaded it into the Veith post gallery (now it is deleted from there), one of the blogs did not, so perhaps the reason given "automatic anti spam controls" was correct. I am slightly suspicious that the suspensions all came at the time the ban on hate speech in Scotland was coming in, and algorithms may have been being tightened.
The Walter Veith video is worth a watch though on various symbolism including freemasonic symbolism, even though tangential to my ban. The Secret behind the Secret Societies who Control the World - Walter Veith [3].
Links
[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20240401173349/https://policy.medium.com/medium-rules-30e5502c4eb4
Appendix 1 Medium Rules
Medium is an open platform that exists to share ideas and perspectives from the world’s most insightful writers, thinkers, and storytellers.
We welcome thoughtful and civil discussion from a broad spectrum of viewpoints. To maintain a safe, respectful, and welcoming environment for a wide range of people to engage in meaningful conversations, we prohibit certain conduct.
In deciding whether there has been a violation of the rules, we will take into consideration things like newsworthiness, the context and nature of the posted information, the likelihood and severity of actual or potential harms, account history, and applicable laws.
Violations of our rules may result in consequences such as account restrictions or suspension of your content. Medium has the sole authority and final decision as to whether content or behavior violates our rules.
To report a violation:
If you find a post or account on Medium that you believe violates these rules, please report it. You can find the report button in the 3-dot menu on every post, response, and account page.
You can use this form to provide more detail or to report other conduct you believe violates our rules. Additionally, you can send an email to trust@medium.com.
Block and mute:
If you find yourself in conflict with another user, we encourage the following:
Block them and move on. You can learn more about blocking here.
Mute them, and they won’t show up in your feeds. You can learn more about muting here.
Remove their responses from your stories. You can learn more about managing and turning off your responses here.
Rules
Capitalized terms here have the same meaning as defined in the Medium Terms of Service.
Threats of violence and incitement
We do not allow content or actions that threaten, encourage, or incite violence against anyone, directly or indirectly.
Hateful content
We do not allow content that constitutes or promotes violence, harassment, or hatred against people based on characteristics like race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, caste, disability, disease, age, sexual orientation, gender, or gender identity.
We do not allow posts or accounts that glorify, celebrate, downplay, or trivialize violence, suffering, abuse, or deaths of individuals or groups. This includes the use of scientific or pseudoscientific claims or misleading statistics to pathologize, dehumanize, or disempower others. We do not allow calls for intolerance, exclusion, or segregation based on protected characteristics, nor do we allow the glorification of groups which do any of the above.
We do not allow posts or accounts that target others with slurs, tropes, or other content that intends to dehumanize, degrade or reinforce negative or harmful stereotypes about a protected category. For example, this may include targeted or intentional misgendering or deadnaming of transgender individuals, or harmfully ableist language.
We do not allow hateful text, images, symbols, or other content, including in your username, profile, or bio.
Harassment
Medium exists to share and discuss ideas. We don’t tolerate harassment, which includes:
Bullying, threatening, mocking, or shaming someone, or posting things likely to encourage others to do so
Engaging in a repetitive or targeted campaign of harassment against someone or a group of people
Using derogatory language, racial slurs, or obscenities to disparage or attack someone or a group of people
Using Medium features like responses, private notes, mentions, follows, lists, highlights, or requests in a way that attempts to or does annoy or harass someone, or to draw inorganic attention to your content on Medium
Privacy and Reputation
We do not allow the following:
Posting images of, transcripts of, copies of, or links to private communications between private individuals without the explicit consent of all parties to the communication. Redacting names or other information does not supplant the need to secure permissions
Doxing, which includes not only private or obscure personal information but also the aggregation of publicly available information to target, shame, blackmail, harass, intimidate, threaten, or endanger a person or group of people
Posting intimate or explicit images taken or posted without the subject’s express consent
Content that violates others’ privacy or personal safety, including sensitive or confidential information such as credit card numbers, social security numbers, non-public phone numbers, physical addresses, email addresses, non-public data, or other similar information
Restricted categories
We do not allow posts or accounts that engage in the following restricted categories of activity:
Promotion of controversial, suspect, or extreme content. You can read more about these policies in our Help Center.
Facilitation of gambling or betting
Facilitation of buying or selling social media interactions, including off-platform
Facilitation of sexual services
Facilitation of copyright or other intellectual property violation
Facilitation or evidence of violating the terms of service of Medium or third party(s)
Providing reviews of businesses or products in a gratuitously harmful or abusive manner
Facilitation of illegal hacking (e.g., stealing credentials, compromising personal data)
Promotion of pseudoscience, disinformation, or other content that is contrary to public health or safety
Related conduct
We do not allow content or accounts that engage in on-platform, off-platform, or cross-platform campaigns of targeting, harassment, hate speech, violence, or disinformation. We may consider off-platform actions in assessing a Medium account, and restrict access or availability to that account.
Graphic content
We do not allow posting, linking to, or otherwise promoting pornographic images or videos. We do allow erotic writing and non-graphic erotic images.
Medium is a large network, and posts can travel in front of all different types of readers. We ask that you be mindful of unintentional viewers when selecting your images.
We do not allow gratuitously graphic or disturbing media, regardless of subject matter.
Exploitation of minors
We do not allow content promoting the sexual, violent, or other exploitation of minors, including the sexualization of fictional minors.
Promotion and glorification of self-harm
We do not allow content or activities that encourage, promote or glorify acts of self-harm, such as cutting, eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia, and suicide. If you encounter users contemplating or threatening self-harm, please report it.
Duplicate Content
We do not allow posting duplicate copies of the same content to Medium, whether from a single account or across multiple accounts, either publicly or as an unlisted story. (You are allowed to cross-post content from your blog to Medium, provided you own the rights for the content.)
Spam or Site Misuse
We do not allow spam or misuse of Medium. All spam or misuse will be immediately removed from Medium without notification. Examples of spam or misuse include:
Posting content primarily to drive traffic to, or increase the search rankings of, an external site, product, or service
Scraping and reposting content from other sources for the primary purpose of generating revenue or other personal gains
Posting duplicate content, whether from a single account or across multiple accounts
Stories where the content is clipped with the purpose of linking to the rest of the article on a different website
Performing a disproportionately large number of interactions, particularly by automated means. This includes bulk or indiscriminate interactions, such as following of other accounts (follow spam) clapping, highlighting, leaving notes, or flagging content
Repeatedly using responses, mentions, or other interactions as a method of promotion or marketing
Participating in bounty campaigns or brigades to artificially inflate rankings for posts, accounts, businesses, or products
Use or re-use content templates with slight modifications across multiple posts and accounts
For each of these behaviors, when we talk about “content,” we mean not only posts but also any other feature that allows you to add your own text or media. When we talk about “interactions,” we mean any feature that allows one user to interact with another person or post.
Copyright and trademark infringement
Respect the copyrights and trademarks of others. Per our Terms of Service, we require users to have permission to post the content they publish on Medium. Additionally, we have specific policies around plagiarism, to which all Medium accounts are held. Users found in violation of our copyright rules are not eligible for warning, appeal, or restoration. Deletion of copyright violations is not grounds for reinstatement.
We respond to notices of alleged infringement as described in our Terms of Service, Copyright and DMCA Policy, and Trademark Policy.
Deceptive conduct
We do not allow deceptive conduct on Medium. This includes:
Posting content or impersonating a person or organization in a way likely to deceive people. Parody and satire are fine, but make clear that is what you’re doing. Our Username Policy has specific requirements for parody accounts
Using Medium for phishing or fraud. Don’t use tags, links, titles, or other metadata in a misleading way. Don’t link to or embed malicious or harmful code or software in your posts
Using deception to generate revenue or traffic
If you have received free goods or services, or anything of value in connection with the topic of a post, you must make this clear.
Ads, Promotions, and Marketing
First party promotion is allowed, and you may promote and link to your own business , website, mailing list, or fundraiser.
Third-party advertising and sponsorships are not allowed. You may not advertise or promote third-party products, services, or brands through Medium posts, publications, or newsletters. This includes images that indicate brand sponsorship in a post or newsletter, or as part of a publication name or logo.
Affiliate links, such as links out to Amazon with an affiliate code, or any other link out where you will receive a commission or other value, are allowed in posts. However, per Federal Trade Commission law, you must disclose the inclusion of these links in your post. This can be a simple sentence in the footer. (for further guidance, see FTC Rules and Guides).
Embedded Content and Collection of Personal Information
To ensure the data privacy and security of our users, embedded content must comply with the following requirements. An “embed” includes a link, form, or a request for information or other content.
Embeds directly collecting data through Medium form fields, comments or other onsite means are not allowed. This includes embeds that facilitate the submission of email addresses, credit card information or other personal information. If you want to collect information from your readers, you will need to follow these requirements:
If you link out from your post on Medium to a form hosted elsewhere, that form must make it clear to a user that they are no longer in the Medium network and the information they disclose is subject to the third-party’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy,
If the link directs users to your own platform to subscribe to your newsletter, blog or other content you create, then in your Medium content immediately next to the link you must disclose that the link will take the user offsite outside of Medium
If your content includes a form that sends user information to you or a third-party, immediately next to or within the form you must disclose that the form will send the user’s information to an offsite third-party outside of Medium that is subject to that offsite third-party’s Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, or offsite outside of Medium, to you directly.
Paid, automatic, bulk, or non-genuine interactions
Medium depends on various user behaviors — like follows and claps — to determine what content to feature and make the site work well for everyone. We don’t allow artificial behaviors that skew this system and as a result degrade or distort other users’ experiences.
This includes:
Buying, selling, or trading in accounts or account interactions — including views, reads, follows, claps, highlights, responses, or other traffic
Using services, apps, or arrangements that offer you more views, reads, follows, claps, or other interactions on your Medium account or content
Registering accounts, posting content, or interacting with users or content automatically, systematically, or programmatically
Cryptocurrency Accounts, Posts, and Publications
Posts and accounts that are focused on launching, announcing, or providing information on cryptocurrencies must meet the requirements listed in our Cryptocurrency Policy. Medium does not endorse or verify any coin, token, financial advice, or similar announcement.
Prohibitions on Use of the Services
You agree not to do, try to do, or cause a third party to do any of the following, except without the express written consent of Medium:
(1) access or tamper with non-public areas of the Services, our computer systems, or the systems of our technical providers;
(2) access or search the Services by any means other than the currently available, published interfaces (e.g., APIs) that we provide;
(3) forge any TCP/IP packet header or any part of the header information in any email or posting, or in any way use the Services to send altered, deceptive, or false source-identifying information;
(4) use the Services in any manner that could disable, overburden, damage, or impair the Services, or interfere with any other use of the Services;
(5) use any software, script, robot, spider or other automatic device, process or means (including crawlers, browser plugins and add-ons or any other technology) to access the Services for any purpose, including without limitation to scrape or otherwise copy any of the data or content on the Services;
(6) use any manual process to monitor or copy any of the data or content on the Services, or to engage in any other unauthorized purpose;
(7) otherwise use any device, software or routine that interferes with the proper working of the Services; or
(8) otherwise attempt to interfere with the proper working of the Services.
Use of custom domain features
Medium provides the ability to point a domain name that you control to a publication on Medium. If you use this custom domain feature, you understand that your publication will still be hosted on Medium and will still be subject to Medium’s Terms of Service. If you use this custom domain feature, you may not do, try to do, or cause a third party to do the following:
(1) Alter the look and feel or transform the content of the webpage, including by injecting ads, inserting tracking code, or altering the Medium look or feel;
(2) Use proxy servers or any other means to short-circuit our rules or circumvent user protections; or
(3) Mislead users about what site they are on or what their actions will do.
Your use of the custom domain feature must comply with our Privacy Policy. Please note that our rules around storing, transferring, and using user data are more user-protective than some other sites’. We do not sell user data or allow tracking of our users across the web. We expect you to uphold these same rules and policies in connection with operating your custom domain.
How to report a violation
If you find a post or account on Medium that violates these rules, please report it in product. You can use this form to provide more detail or to report other conduct you believe violates our rules. Additionally, you can send us an email to trust@medium.com.
If you break the rules
We strive to be fair, but we reserve the right to suspend accounts or remove content, without notice, for any reason, particularly to protect our services, infrastructure, users, or community. If you attempt to evade suspension by creating new accounts or posts, we will suspend your new accounts and posts.
Notice
Upon investigating or disabling content associated with your account, we will notify you, unless we believe your account is automated or operating in bad faith, or that notifying you is likely to cause, maintain or exacerbate harm to someone.
Appeals
If you believe your content or account has been restricted or disabled in error, or believe there is relevant context we were not aware of in reaching our determination, you can write to us at trust@medium.com. We will consider all good faith efforts to appeal.
Government Takedown Requests
If Medium receives a request from a government actor to restrict access to content associated with your account, we will notify you unless we are prohibited by law or believe doing so may endanger others. Where applicable, we will work to limit legally-ordered content restrictions to jurisdictions where we have a good faith belief that we are legally required to restrict the content. Medium submits to the Lumen database government requests to restrict access to content (redacted where appropriate to protect privacy or prevent harm to a person).
We may enforce, or not enforce, these policies at our sole discretion. These policies don’t create a duty or contractual obligation for us to act.
We also may change these rules at any time. We track changes to our rules on Github so you can see how they evolve.
Medium is committed to providing a transparent, open platform for expression and therefore supports the goals and spirit of The Santa Clara Principles on Transparency and Accountability in Content Moderation as a starting point for further discussion.
Updated June 2023
Foxblog Social Media
foxblog3 Substack Blog 2021- present Foxblog3 Substack Blog and Newsletter
foxblog2 current wordpress blog https://cathyfoxblog2.wordpress.com/
foxblog1 old wordpress blog 2012-2022 https://cathyfox.wordpress.com/
foxblog4 wordpress https://foxblog4.wordpress.com/
CathyFoxSubstack (archive of cathyfoxblog1) Cathy Fox Blog WordPress Archive on Substack
Telegram FoxyFoxyWolf Channel https://t.me/wolfchannel2
Telegram Foxy Wolf Chat Group https://t.me/foxywolfchannelgroup
Bastyon https://bastyon.com/foxyfoxy
Email cathyfox@ zoho.com
RSS Feeds
Medium is terrible. At least it was during the lockdown period of time.